The Kominsky Method Is an Embarrassing Waste of Time for Everyone Involved
Written by Ian Thomas Malone, Posted in Blog, TV Reviews
The opening scene of The Kominsky Method throws a nod to non-binary people, an inclusive tone contradicted a few minutes later when Michael Douglas’ title character holds an embarrassing public inquisition to his acting class over feminine hygiene products clogging his studio’s bathroom. This contrast embodies the struggle at the heart of the show, acutely aware of the era it occupies while unable to resist the low-hanging fruit of sexist toilet humor. Quite unsurprisingly, The Kominsky Method is exactly what you’d expect if you asked someone to dream up what a Chuck Lorre take on Grace & Frankie might look like from a straight man’s perspective. The result is a pathetic attempt to sound intellectual while offering little other than the basic novelty of watching Michael Douglas interact with Alan Arkin in the comfort of your own home.
The Kominsky Method is ostensibly a show about aging. Douglas’ Sandy Kominsky is a moderately successful acting teacher who dates his students even though he’s demonstrably aware that such behavior is hardly acceptable in the #MeToo era. Arkin plays Norman Newlander, his agent who spends much of the season grieving his wife, who dies early on in the series. The show chooses a grand life question to ponder in each episode, picking at it like an unwanted salad that comes with your meal, something that doesn’t need to be seen to completion.
Occasionally, The Kominsky Method hints at modern culture, like political correctness, as if it wants to say something meaningful about the nature of humor in an era where marginalized people are allowed to publicly object. Problem is, the show really doesn’t have anything to say besides a snippet of commentary one might pull from a segment on Fox News. It never commits to any particular direction, particularly on display with the handling of Newlander’s wife, whose terminal illness is originally exploited to further Komsinsky’s romantic storyline before becoming the main plot driver for the next few episodes. The show is desperate to sound insightful, but it can’t seem to make anything out of the scenarios it forces its characters to play out.
The Kominsky Method isn’t so much bad as it is simply not good, relying extensively on the name recognition of its stars to substitute for an indecisive narrative. The entire show is constructed similarly to a scene that might be performed in an acting class, an incomplete scenario used to showcase the talent of the actors. Douglas and Arkin are talented, but this was a given already. The show is far too content to coast along on their abilities.
Part of what makes Douglas such a charm in recent movies such as Ant-Man and the Wasp is that he genuinely looks like he’s having fun. His own enjoyment is less convincing in The Kominsky Method, like a college freshman out of a place at a foreign film screening where they don’t understand the jokes. The Kominsky Method doesn’t really have jokes, but rather things to smile at occasionally if for no other reason than to simulate the concept of enjoyment.
The Kominsky Method is very watchable television, but it’s an empty experience once one moves past the novelty aspect. The beauty of television is that the viewer isn’t necessarily required to do that. A person can sit down and enjoy two actors working off each other in the latter stages of their careers, but the experience could have, and should have, been so much more. The Kominsky Method might be Netflix’s laziest offering that anyone would be expected to take seriously. The “peak TV” label is one handed out generously in this era, sometimes, sadly, to shows that expect it to be given as a birthright before laying down anything of substance to merit such praise.
innane review….Must be written by a 30’s somehting psuedo intellctual..with no intellect. Not noticing the crisp dialogue..perfect timing deliveries and great written lines…Not ALL actors here..Reread the Brothers K if you want serious stuff…but I dont think you would get it…get it..
A pathetic piece of garbage with a few touching moments.
Whoa. That was not my experience at all. Mr. Ian Thomas Malone, did you and I watch the same series? In the series I saw, Alan Arkin stole the show — the whole show — and Michael Douglas, though his character got top (only) billing, generously gave every actor in every scene room to roam… graciously playing the foil, straightman…letting each shine bright… the acting equivalent of soccer’s perfect, essential assist that goes unnoticed because it allows a teammate to score a goal.
Some moments of writing were nothing short of brilliant. The superb supporting cast and cameo bits played to the hilt. Timing, that gorgeous element of comedy was evidenced, well, time and time again…though not quite always… and never better than in Arkin’s most memorable of many excellent moments, when he perfected the ‘no-liner’ and showed all comedians who struggle for the most concise two-liners and one-liners, what can be done so well with just subtle facial movements and one arm arcing in front of himself, Brancusi-Bird in Space-like, just what a true master of comedy-pathos-human condition can do.
The essence of Ian’s review is that the Kominsjy Method is not enjoyable to watch, yet it gets over a 90% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes. If I were the reviewer this would worry me. Could he be out of touch?
Kind of like the media’s view of Trump. They condemn him as incompetent yet about half the country voted for him and think he’s doing a good job.
Interesting.
What a waste of time reading this article. The Kominsky Methos is very clever, some times it is getting emotional and hilarious, and most of the actors and actress are real great.
I hated everything about it. I feel like the people who enjoy this show think that Obama was a good president, Because they are passive viewers rather than active viewers. The audience of Chuck Lorre productions don’t want to think about whats funny or clever, they want to be told whats funny. They want to feel intelligent, connected, and relevant. I can sum up this entire response with “Ok boomer”
Bringing politic to a discussion about a fucking Netflix show is ridiculous if there’s anyone desperate to feel intelligent is you lol, plus ending an argument where you pretend to be smarter and superior than others by saying “OK boomer” is hilarious XD
Just chill kiddy, one day your brain will grow up, hopefully.
But thanks for making my day, they say laughter is the best medicine, if that’s true your hilarious stupidity should heal cancer lmao.
BTW the problem isn’t in disliking something others like, the problem is attacking the those people like sn insecure child that needs a seal of approval to like something, so go get some band-aid for fragile ego of yours and a pacifier to stop crying and F off XD
This was precious
Proving me right I see, thanks kiddo, this is truly precious, if you can’t handle the heat don’t burn people in the first, specially just because your sad people don’t agree with you 😘
Can’t wait to see the next 4 syllables your brain is gonna come up with, but I’ll throw your brain a bone of “Don’t bother because I won’t even check” “OK Boomer”? 😏😂
I agree with the author “The Kominsky Method isn’t so much bad as it is simply not good, relying extensively on the name recognition of its stars to substitute for an indecisive narrative” but would like to add that there seems to be too much ‘real life’ dramas streaming today. What about good ole entertainment when you look forward to anticipating the next thing – scene to happen?
I will never get the time back that I spent watching this series. On the positive note, I didn’t make it till the end. phew.. and Yuck!
Follow Us On Facebook
Estradiol Illusions
Estradiol Illusions on Apple
Estradiol Illusions on Spotify
Twitter Feed
The Estradiol Illusions Podcast
Entertainment & LGBTQ Issues show hosted by Ian Thomas Malone (@ianthomasmalone)
Our holiday coverage continues with an ITM personal favorite, and not just because she bore a resemblance to the boy as a young child. The Snowman is a beautifully animated special that tugs at all the right heartstrings. Ian unpacks her relationship to the special and its themes.
Note: Ian spends the first five minutes talking about EI’s 200th episode milestone. Listeners looking just for Snowman are recommended to skip the first few minutes. Happy holidays everyone!
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Archives
Ian Thomas Malone is proudly powered by WordPress